Michael K. Gibson, MD, PhD, on Metastatic Esophageal Squamous Cell Carcinoma: New First-Line Systemic Treatment Options

NCCN 2023 Annual Conference


Michael K. Gibson, MD, PhD, of Vanderbilt-Ingram Cancer Center, discusses the importance of developing additional treatment strategies for patients with advanced or metastatic esophageal squamous cell carcinoma and describes the role of immune checkpoint inhibitors. Dr. Gibson also reviews the available evidence on the use of nivolumab in this patient population.


Disclaimer: This video transcript has not been proofread or edited and may contain errors.
Michael K. Gibson: Esophageal cancer is the seventh most common cause of cancer worldwide, but also the sixth most common cause of death. There are two histologies, squamous cell cancer and adenocarcinoma. Squamous cell cancer predominates making up about 90% of all cases of cancer of the esophagus, and most of these cases are outside of America. When the patient's cancer becomes recurrent or metastatic, we treat with palliative intent, so time and quality. Historically, we've picked cytotoxic chemo from one of three categories, taxanes, platinums and fluoropyrimidines. And with those combinations, even now, the median overall survival only approaches 10 months. So there's been a great need for advances in treatment of this squamous cell subtype of esophageal cancer. And unlike adenocarcinoma, which has four predictive biomarkers, squamous cell cancer of the esophagus has none. Fortunately, with the advent of immunotherapy, we've made a fair amount of progress. And there are three randomized clinical trials that have been presented over the past year or two, which demonstrate the power of immunotherapy for squamous cell cancer to the esophagus. The first one, KEYNOTE 590, has a baseline cytotoxic regimen of cisplatin and 5-FU. The study, which included 70% squamous cell cancers, added pembrolizumab to that base combination for overall survival. The hazard ratio was approximately 0.7, and it did not cross one. So the confidence interval as well as the hazard ratio made this study a statistically significant and positive study. The second study CheckMate 648, similar setting, first line, recurrent metastatic, but it had three arms instead of two. The baseline arm, again was cisplatin, 5-FU, then the comparator arms were the same, plus or minus nivolumab. And then perhaps a more novel and useful arm, which was a combination of nivolumab and ipilimumab without cytotoxic chemotherapy. And again, the experimental arms were successful and the hazard ratio was approximately 0.7. The third trial done primarily as a group in China, is called ESCORT-1st. Again, had a baseline chemotherapy, but this time it was a taxane, plus a platinum, plus or minus camrelizumab, which was another check point inhibitor. And perhaps not surprising, this study was also positive for the addition of immunotherapy to cytotoxic chemo, hazard ratio, again, hovers around 0.7. I should note that none of these trials had marker selection, and the toxicity of each of them was as expected when you add immunotherapy to chemotherapy. So this represents a paradigm shift in the treatment of frontline recurrent metastatic squamous cell cancer of the esophagus. The median overall survival, has approached 12 months. And to reiterate, the hazard ratios were in the mid to low 0.7. The future will involve using this new paradigm, chemo plus immunotherapy or dual immunotherapy, plus additional approaches to improve the median overall survival to 12 months and beyond.

Related Videos

Elena Ratner, MD, MBA on Sexual Identity and Function in Cancer Survivors

Elena Ratner, MD, MBA, of Yale Cancer Center/Smilow Cancer Hospital, discusses sexuality, intimacy, fertility, and menopause as important aspects of women’s cancer survivorship and the many effects of treatment on these issues. They often go unacknowledged in the medical community, Dr. Ratner says, because of a lack of knowledge and resources. She describes interventions, including holistic, hormonal, behavioral, psychological, and interdisciplinary approaches.

Solid Tumors

Mitesh J. Borad, MD, on Hepatobiliary Cancers: Management Updates

Mitesh J. Borad, MD, of the Mayo Clinic Comprehensive Cancer Center, discusses the expanding number of options in immunotherapies for patients with advanced hepatobiliary cancers, applying targeted treatments to this disease, and the importance of genomic profiling in patients with biliary tract cancers.


Jordan McPherson, PharmD, MS, BCOP, on Managing Immunotherapy-Related Toxicities

Jordan McPherson, PharmD, MS, BCOP, of the Huntsman Cancer Institute at the University of Utah, summarizes a case-based panel discussion on best practices in caring for patients with immune-related adverse events. He focuses on pneumonitis, which can occur with immune checkpoint inhibitor therapy, detailing factors such as comorbidities, infectious etiology, and disease progression; the need to consider myositis and myasthenia gravis in patients who develop immune-related myocarditis; and oral toxicities including mucositis and sicca syndrome.

Solid Tumors
Lung Cancer

Ella A. Kazerooni, MD, on Lung Cancer Screening: Benefits and Challenges

Ella A. Kazerooni, MD, of the University of Michigan Rogel Cancer Center, discusses reducing cancer deaths in the United States by identifying patients at risk for lung cancer. Engaging with primary care physicians and facilitating referrals are keys to a successful lung cancer screening program, she says, as is working with a nurse care coordinator.

CNS Cancers
Solid Tumors

Louis B. Nabors, MD, on NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology Updates for CNS Cancers in Adults

Louis B. Nabors, MD, of the O’Neal Comprehensive Cancer Center at UAB, discusses the three subtypes of adult gliomas classified by the World Health Organization, treatments influenced by IDH mutation status, the roles of radiotherapy and chemotherapy, molecular testing, and pseudoprogression and RANO (response assessment in neuro-oncology) criteria.