Cancer Drug Shortages Mean Higher Costs and Greater Risk for Patients
A national survey of health professionals showed that drug shortages are taking a heavy toll on cancer patients, forcing treatment changes and delays that for some patients meant worse outcomes, more therapy-related complications, and higher costs. St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital investigators played an important role in the study.
The survey is the first to focus specifically on the impact of cancer-related drug shortages. It was conducted by the Hematology/Oncology Pharmacy Association and focused on a 12-month period ending in October 2011. The results appear in the April 1 edition of the American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy.
Survey Details
The survey queried oncology pharmacists and others involved in managing cancer drug shortages for academic medical centers, community hospitals, and other cancer treatment facilities nationwide. Of the 243 individuals who completed the survey, 98% reported having dealt with a shortage of at least one chemotherapy agent or other essential cancer-related drug in the previous 12 months. Ninety-three percent reported that shortages forced delays in chemotherapy administration or other changes in cancer drug therapy.
Researchers found the shortages also disrupted cancer research and added to the cost and risks associated with cancer treatment. One institution linked a patient’s death to a shortage-related medication mistake. Overall, 16% of respondents tied shortages to adverse patient outcomes, including disease progression or more treatment-related complications.
“This survey documents the risk that drug shortages pose to cancer patients of all ages,” said the study’s senior author, James Hoffman, PharmD, an associate member of the St. Jude Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences and the hospital’s Medication Outcomes and Safety Officer. “To cure cancer patients we must often use complex treatment regimens, and shortages add unnecessary complexity. Unlike medications for other diseases, there are few, if any, therapeutically equivalent alternatives available for many oncology drugs in short supply.
Tracking the Shortage
“Drug supplies remain unpredictable and serious problems persist,” Dr. Hoffman said. In February, the University of Utah Drug Information Service was tracking national and regional shortages of more than 320 drugs, which is the highest number since 2010. The University of Utah Drug Information Service tracks drug shortages and provides advice about managing shortages through the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.
The survey follows an earlier St. Jude–led study that linked a shortage of the chemotherapy drug mechlorethamine (Mustargen) to a greater risk of relapse for some young patients with Hodgkin lymphoma. Relapse meant those patients underwent additional intensive therapy that left them at greater risk for infertility and other treatment-related health problems later.
Multiple factors contribute to drug shortages, including manufacturing and quality problems, production delays, and discontinuations. Earlier studies have shown that most shortages occur in the supply chain of generic injectable drugs, particularly medications to combat cancer and infections. In 2012, new federal legislation gave the FDA additional tools to prevent and ease drug shortages, including requiring manufacturers to report anticipated supply problems of key medications. “While the FDA and others have worked diligently to address the problem, additional action is needed to address continuing shortages,” Dr. Hoffman said.
Negative Effect on Practices
The survey found shortages increase health-care costs as scarcity drives up the price and requires staff time to manage the problem. About one-third of institutions in this survey reported pharmacy staff spent at least 20 hours each week working on issues related to the drug shortage. That included time spent trying to find scarce medications to purchase or identify alternatives. Eighty-five percent of respondents reported shortages led to higher medical costs.
Drug shortages also disrupted the clinical trials that are essential for developing new cancer treatments. This survey found that shortages forced 44% of institutions to either halt or delay enrollment in clinical trials. The problem also led some providers to change or omit medications.
In this survey, the drugs most frequently reported as being in short supply were fluorouracil, leucovorin, liposomal doxorubicin, and paclitaxel. Such shortages hit patients battling ovarian, breast, and colorectal cancers particularly hard. For some patients, the survey found shortages meant traveling to other institutions for treatment or receiving alternative medications. For other patients, it meant treatment was delayed or continued with either lower doses of the missing drugs or without the drugs at all.
Ali McBride, PharmD, The Ohio State University, is the first and corresponding author. Other authors are Lisa Holle, University of Connecticut; Colleen Westendorf, formerly of University of Kentucky and now of St. Jude; Margaret Sidebottom and Niesha Griffith, Ohio State; and Raymond Muller, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York.
The study was funded in part by a grant (CA21765) from the National Institutes of Health and ALSAC.
The content in this post has not been reviewed by the American Society of Clinical Oncology, Inc. (ASCO®) and does not necessarily reflect the ideas and opinions of ASCO®.
